Book Review: Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys

Cover from the New York Times Best Seller "Raising Cain, Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys" by Dan Kindlon, PhD, and Michael Thompson, PhD, published by Ballantine Books
By Sarah Simons

Being female, I have always been curious about the inner workings of the male psyche. I’ve read stuff like Men are from Mars, and Wild at Heart, but never anything quite so bittersweet as Raising Cain, perhaps because the others are more about men, and this book is about boys. It is a comprehensive look at how boys in our society are often raised in a way that shorts them many of the emotional skills necessary to function well, and, gladly, gives suggestions for how to protect and enhance the emotional health of boys as they grow through adolescence into manhood.

One recurring theme throughout the book is the idea of “the Big Impossible”, a definition of masculinity that is based on performance. The problem with this is the emphasis on accomplishment, rarely sustainable for any length of time, rather than the more nuanced qualities of just being a man. Chapters address early development and school experiences, family, peer and romantic relationships, sexuality, troubling issues like drug use, violence perpetrated by boys, and isolation that can lead to depression. Each well-researched and engaging chapter creates the blueprint for rethinking how we approach boys in the realm of emotions, emphasizing the need to provide a whole collection of emotional materials and tools for boys to build a complete life that is a true reflection of a whole person.

The last chapter is a great Finale to the book, offering seven practical and substantial suggestions for teaching “emotional literacy” to those parenting, coaching, educating, or just hangin’ out with boys. It suggests that many boys are taught emotions in a way that falls short. If we give then the words so that they can understand the difference between anger and frustration, sadness and fear, compassion and warmth, it would be one of the greatest gifts we can share.

They really are a wonder, these boys, and it’s good to be aware of how we can encourage them toward emotional health and wholeness. I would heartily recommend this book to anyone concerned for this and future generations. It might even shed a little light on the adult men in your life!

Bur Bur’s Boating ABC’s Book Cover - 2008 Teacher’s Choice Awards and iParenting Media Awards winner and Silver 2008 Mom’s Choice Award recipientBur Bur’s Fishing Adventure Book CoverBur Bur Throws Out the First Pitch Book children’s book cover - iParenting Media Award winner and Silver 2008 Mom’s Choice Award WinnerAnna Goes Hiking Book Cover - iParenting Media Award winner, Silver Mom’s Choice Award Winner
Book Covers from the award winning Bur Bur and Friend’s children’s book series: Bur Bur and Friends is a cast of multicultural characters who educate kids about self-esteem, sports, outdoor exploration and active play though their experiences.

Parenting Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory Digg!
Seed Newsvine Google PageRank Checker - Page Rank Calculator Add This Blog to the JacketFlap Blog Reader StumbleUpon
Parenting Blogs - Blog Top Sites Add to Technorati Favorites
Blog Carnival Index - browse the archives
Local Directory for Minneapolis, MNBlog DirectoryMy site was nominated for Best Parenting Blog! For Local Blog
in Minneapolis

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Technorati Favorites
  • StumbleUpon
  • Share/Bookmark

2 Responses to “Book Review: Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys”

  1. Children's Bedroom Furniture Says:

    As middle aged adult male who has overcome depression as well as a host of other emotional challenges, this could be a good read to help further understanding of my self in addition to my 18 year old son.

    That emphasis on accomplishment you mentioned, wow! Boy can I relate…

    Thank you for the tip!!!

  2. Helene Says:

    Thanks for sharing this book review with the readers of The Work at Home Family Carnival.

Leave a Reply